Scary Markets and Retirement: Why the 5 Years Around Retirement Matter Most


When you’re 35, a market drop is a sale. When you’re 62 and planning to retire next year, it can feel like a threat to everything you’ve worked for.

That feeling is normal. Behavioral economists call it loss aversion: a loss stings more than an equal gain feels good. And this fall has given plenty of reason to feel it, with tech stocks sliding and big daily swings back in the headlines.

Here’s the part most articles skip. Near retirement, that worry isn’t entirely irrational. The years just before and just after you retire are when a market decline can do the most lasting damage to a plan. The good news is that this risk is well understood, and most of the work to manage it happens before the market drops, not during.

I’m Dwight Dettloff, CPA, CFP®, a fee-only fiduciary financial planner at Winding Trail Financial Planning in Lafayette, Colorado. I work with people who are within about five years of retirement or already retired, in the Boulder County area and across the country, helping them plan their investments, retirement income, and taxes together. Here’s how I think about scary markets when retirement is close.

Why the Order of Returns Matters

While you’re working and saving, the order of good and bad years doesn’t matter much. Once you start withdrawing, it matters a lot. Every withdrawal means selling something, and selling when prices are down means selling more shares to get the same dollars. Those shares aren’t there for the recovery.

This is called sequence-of-returns risk. Here’s a simple hypothetical. Two retirees each start with $1,000,000 and withdraw $50,000 at the start of every year. Over 10 years they get the exact same annual returns, just in opposite order. One hits two down years (−20% and −10%) right away. The other hits them at the end.

Same returns, same withdrawals, same average. After 10 years, the retiree who hit the down years first has about $722,000. The other has about $1,020,000. The only difference is when the bad years showed up.

Before retirement, an early bad year is something time and new contributions can help fix. After withdrawals start, you have less of both.

The Retirement “Red Zone”

Many planners call the roughly five years before and five years after your retirement date the “red zone.” Three things make this stretch different:

  • Your balance is near its largest. A 20% drop on a large balance is the biggest dollar loss you’ll ever see.

  • You have fewer paychecks left. There’s less time to keep adding money while prices are low.

  • Withdrawals are about to start, or already have. Selling to fund spending is what turns a temporary drop into a lasting one.

That doesn’t mean the answer is to move everything to cash. Retirement can last 25 or 30 years, and going too conservative brings its own risk: money that doesn’t keep up with inflation. (We cover that in The Silent Retirement Risk.) The goal is a plan that doesn’t force you to sell stocks at a bad time.

If you’re about five years out, our 12-step checklist for the five years before retirement is a good companion to this article.

What to Do Before the Next Downturn

The best time to prepare for a scary market is when it isn’t scary. These steps are most useful if they’re in place ahead of time.

  1. Give each part of your portfolio a job. Money you’ll spend in the next two to three years belongs in cash and high-quality bonds. Money you won’t touch for many years can stay invested for growth. When stocks fall, you spend from the short-term bucket and give the long-term bucket time to recover. This doesn’t prevent losses, but it can reduce the chance you’ll have to sell stocks after a drop.

  2. Know your real spending number. Split it into essentials (housing, food, insurance, taxes) and flexible spending (travel, gifts, projects). The essentials are what your plan has to cover in a bad year.

  3. Set your “bad year” rules in advance. Decide now what you’d adjust if your portfolio fell significantly. Maybe you skip an inflation raise, push a big trip back a year, or trim flexible spending. A decision made calmly is easier to follow than one made in the middle of a selloff.

  4. Diversify on purpose. Different investments react differently to the same news. The purpose of diversification is reducing risk, not maximizing return. It helps smooth out the ride.

  5. Rebalance on a schedule, not on headlines. A set schedule or set ranges for your mix keep you from reacting to every news cycle.

What to Do When Markets Are Falling

Spend from cash and bonds first. This is what the short-term bucket is for. Drawing from it gives your stocks time to recover instead of selling them low.

Don’t try to time it. Selling everything and waiting it out sounds sensible, but you have to be right twice: once when you sell and again when you buy back in. (More on that in Time in the Market vs. Timing the Market.) Before making a change, ask whether it’s because of the market or because your life has changed.

Look at a Roth conversion. This is where a down market can work in your favor. When account values are lower, converting the same number of shares from a traditional IRA to a Roth costs less in tax. If those shares recover, the recovery happens inside the Roth, where qualified withdrawals are tax-free. Whether it makes sense depends on your tax bracket, Medicare premium thresholds, and how you’ll pay the tax, so run the numbers first. (More in Are Roth Conversions Worth It?)

Harvest losses in taxable accounts. Selling an investment at a loss and replacing it with a similar (not “substantially identical”) one can create a tax loss without changing your overall mix much. Losses offset capital gains and up to $3,000 of ordinary income a year, and unused losses carry forward. Watch the wash-sale rule if you buy the same investment back within 30 days.

Rebalance if your plan calls for it. Rebalancing after a drop means buying what’s down. It feels uncomfortable, which is why a pre-set rule helps.

Check in, not constantly. Looking at your balance every day rarely leads to better decisions. A scheduled review with your advisor usually does.

Turn off the news and go live your life. Financial news is built to keep you watching, and a scary headline every hour won’t make your plan any better. Take a hike, get out on the bike, call a friend, spend time with the grandkids, or pick back up the hobby you’ve been meaning to get to. Retirement is about the life you’re building, not the number on today’s statement. If your plan is sound, the market doesn’t need you watching it.

Your Biggest Levers Aren’t in Your Portfolio

You can’t control the market. You can control a surprising amount around it.

  • When you claim Social Security. Claiming earlier means smaller withdrawals from your portfolio during a downturn, but a permanently smaller check. Delaying means larger withdrawals now in exchange for a bigger benefit for life, including for a surviving spouse. Neither is automatically right. It depends on your health, your spouse, and the rest of your income.

  • A little earned income. Part-time or consulting work for a year or two can sharply reduce what you need to withdraw while the market recovers. If you’ve already claimed Social Security and you’re under full retirement age, keep the earnings test in mind: in 2026, benefits are reduced once earnings pass $24,480 and $25,560 for 2027 (SSA).

  • Your retirement date. Working a few more months can help, but a bad market alone shouldn’t decide your date. If the plan was built with downturns in mind, it may not need to change.

  • Your spending. A temporary trim to flexible spending in a down year can go a long way. This is where the “bad year” rules you set in advance pay off.

The Bottom Line

Scary markets are part of investing, and they’ll show up during your retirement too. What matters most near retirement isn’t predicting the next drop. It’s having a plan that doesn’t force you to sell at the wrong time, and knowing in advance what you’ll do when it happens.

A plan you made in a calm market is the one you should follow in a scary one.

That plan should come first. In my view, financial advice should work in this order:

  1. Define your purpose.

  2. Build a personalized financial plan based on that purpose.

  3. Build a portfolio in service of your purpose and plan.

Too often, our industry starts with the portfolio and rarely, if ever, gets to the purpose behind it. If that’s been your experience, we’re here to help, in that order.

If you’re within about five years of retirement and aren’t sure how your plan would hold up in a downturn, that’s exactly the kind of question we work through with clients. Start here to download our free guide, Seven Essentials for Successful Investing in Retirement, or request a 30-minute intro call.

Thanks for reading.

-Dwight

Dwight Dettloff, CPA, CFP®

P.S. If this fall’s market swings are keeping you up at night, treat that as useful information, not a reason to act. It’s a sign to stress-test your plan now, while you have time to adjust, instead of in the middle of the next downturn.

FAQs About Market Downturns Near Retirement

What is sequence-of-returns risk?

Sequence-of-returns risk is the risk that the order of investment returns, not just the average, affects how long your savings last. It matters most once you start withdrawing. Losses early in retirement force you to sell more shares at low prices, leaving less invested for the recovery.

When is sequence-of-returns risk the highest?

It’s generally highest in the roughly five years before and five years after your retirement date. Your balance is near its peak, you have fewer working years to recover, and withdrawals are about to begin or already have.

Should I move to cash if the market drops right before I retire?

Usually not all of it. Moving everything to cash means you have to be right twice, once when you sell and again when you buy back in. A retirement can last 25 to 30 years, so most retirees still need some growth. A better approach is to hold enough in cash and bonds to cover the next few years of withdrawals. In other words, right-size your portfolio based on your plan and your needs, not on what the market is doing this month.

How much cash should a retiree keep for a down market?

Many planners suggest holding about two to three years of planned portfolio withdrawals in cash and high-quality shorter-term bonds. The right amount depends on your other income, like Social Security or a pension, and how flexible your spending is.

Some retirees go a step further with an approach called asset-liability matching. They set aside high-quality bonds to cover about five to eight years of planned spending. That might be a ladder of individual bonds that mature as the money is needed, or, for simplicity, bond funds with durations matched to when the spending will happen. The right setup depends on the person or family. Either way, that spending is less tied to what the stock market does, which can make it easier to leave stocks alone during a downturn. The tradeoff is that more money in bonds usually means less long-term growth.

Is a down market a good time for a Roth conversion?

It can be. When account values are lower, converting the same number of shares from a traditional IRA to a Roth costs less in tax, and any recovery happens inside the Roth. Whether it makes sense depends on your tax bracket, Medicare premium thresholds, and how you’d pay the tax.

For more, see Are Roth Conversions Worth It?

Should I delay retirement if the market is down?

Not necessarily. If your plan already accounts for downturns, with cash set aside and flexible spending rules, a bad market alone may not need to change your date. Working a few more months, part-time income, or trimming spending are other levers to consider.

That said, working a little longer can help in several ways at once. It can delay the start of portfolio withdrawals, shorten the number of years you rely on your savings, and give you more time to contribute to your employer’s retirement plan, possibly with a match. For many people, these are also their highest-earning years. And when markets feel out of control, your work timeline is something you may be able to control, so continuing to work isn’t an unreasonable choice.

Flexibility is the key, and it depends on your circumstances. If your plan says you’re ready, you may not need to wait. Life doesn’t always follow the plan, either. I work with people who need to cut back their hours to care for a loved one, and a plan built with flexibility in mind can make room for that.

Disclosures

The hypothetical example in this article is for illustration only. Both hypothetical retirees start with $1,000,000 and withdraw $50,000 at the start of each year. The annual returns used are −20%, −10%, 5%, 10%, 12%, 8%, 15%, 10%, 7%, and 13%, in that order for one retiree and in reverse order for the other. That is an average of 5.0% per year, or about 4.4% compounded. It does not represent any specific investment, account, or actual results, and it does not reflect fees, taxes, or inflation. Actual returns will vary, and past performance does not guarantee future results.

This material has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is not intended to provide, and should not be relied on for, investment, tax, legal, or accounting advice. You should consult your own competent financial, tax, legal, and/or accounting advisors before engaging in any transaction.

Disclaimer: None of the information provided herein is intended as investment, tax, accounting or legal advice, as an offer or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell, or as an endorsement, of any company, security, fund, or other securities or non-securities offering. The information should not be relied upon for purposes of transacting securities or other investments. Your use of the information is at your sole risk. The content is provided ‘as is’ and without warranties, either expressed or implied. Winding Trail Financial Planning, LLC does not promise or guarantee any income or particular result from your use of the information contained herein. Under no circumstances will Winding Trail Financial Planning, LLC be liable for any loss or damage caused by your reliance on the information contained herein. It is your responsibility to evaluate any information, opinion, or other content contained.

Plan Your Next Chapter

Download our free guide "Seven Essentials for Successful Investing in Retirement" and get clarity on what really matters for your retirement success.

Preparing for Retirement Guide